Here is what the person wrote
- so sad when this happens. I won't buy from Annies attic because they are closing down the free distribution of patterns in this way. Please don't let your copy right go ladies. Commercialisation of old time arts and crafts is too much!
To anonymous.
You are free to feel that way. You are welcome to boycott Annie's Attic and my blog. Please move off the grid it will save the rest of us a lot of grief and you will be much happier. But in doing that I hope you have the knowledge and skills how to make your own thread to weave your own clothes, grow your own food build a house and so on. Commercialism = commerce = barter and trading of ideas and goods. You better be 100% self sufficient with out any one else.
But for me Annie's Attic was a major blessing for my family has had some hard times the last few years that I have not posted on here too personal. Having people buy a book that had several patterns that I never would have made otherwise (helped us greatly financial). So no one would have had those patterns if Annie's Attic had not commissioned a book. Which the sale of paid for bills and my family had food on the table, lots of medical expenses paid and so on. I understand people wanting free things but I also understand artisans needing to feed their families and for the need for them to be paid for their hard earned skills. This didn't take anything away from anyone the tutorial plus the now patterns that Annie's requested are still available in book and PDF formats and there is more variety for those who can only follow patterns and can not make things up on the fly. It is a blessing not the opposite. There are plenty of free things on my blog that people are very grateful for but in all honesty that is me being nice to people I don't know which isn't always the most beneficial for my family. Same is true for other artisans we love to share our work we do it for the love of it and a lot of times we don't get paid ( most of the time) but it is nice to get appreciated, and thanks and paid every now and again too (far to far apart).
With out commercialism of old time arts most of them would be dead the Internet , books and their publishing companies will take our art to new audiences is absolutely a blessing. My goal when I started this blog was to write a book (I have a hard time writing and being concise and clear scared to death of writing actually). But I wanted to be commercial and leave some legacy for my children that they could see and hold. I have written an entire book had a chapter in another edited two other books and been in quiet a number of magazines/emags and in over sea newspapers. I don't see that commercialism has hurt my family it has made my family stronger and brought me out of that shell. It has brought more people to my blog because they now know of me and it because of those other mediums and they come here and find more info and are surprised by all the free things. I have an entire year of free tutorials that are happening on this blog that I am currently in production of. I have over lots of patterns for free on ravelry and you are complaining about 9 patterns that would never have existed if it wasn't for Annie’s Attic that and 1 free tutorial when I have over 100 free on here. REALLY!!! Because your comment makes me want to remove everything that is free on my blog and on ravelry because you sound so ungrateful and a cheapskate who wants everything with out paying for anything.
You do realize that almost every tutorial on my blog has some where between 30 and 90 hours to make from making the item, making pdfs, drafting patterns, to photographing, editing photos, writing up a tutorial and doing lay out so let say I have 100 tutorial on here that is 3000 to 9000 hours of my time (closer to the later and that doesn't even cover the other 1000+ posts on here that are information too and take hours to do as well that takes more thousands of hours). You seem to think you have a right to have for free without even a thank you and you are to afraid to even write your real name you write anonymous.
I get paid to teach classes the tutorials on here take more time than teaching a class because I have to write them all out instead of just explaining which is fast. Then take photos which takes forever instead of just making the item. You should pay me for this free knowledge that I have spent many years learning and paying for. I have taken classes so I could learn from little old ladies in their homes dying arts because I can't find information any where else or buying books that are rare and hard to find in different languages and trying to decipher what I see in these old images to figure out how to make the items I see. Well that money sure is not in my pocket so I can put food on the table feeding my family. It was and is me sharing my love of what I do with those that are grateful for it and want to learn and don't know where to begin to find information. It is also so that when my children grow up if anything happens to me they can still have the knowledge in my head and carry on what I know and love. I am fine with that copyright going to Annie's Attic I want to make more books too it was fun and I enjoyed it.
Ladies if you can feed your family and work from home and be a full time mom go to all the school events and take care of the kids when they are sick by all means give up a copyright or two or more.
I am open minded and let the above comment be published. I want people to understand with out commercialism on some things a lot of the old arts would die real quick. Books are long lived I have books in my home that are over 100 years old they have survived a long time and I still love them they are the knowledge of generations before me that thought enough to put their knowledge into a book and put it for sale. I wasn't even alive when they wrote them but I buy them old and used and enjoy and love them and learn much from them.
Knowledge gained free is usually worth what you paid for it NOTHING!!! Knowledge you have to earn or work for or even pay for is valued and passed on and down for generations to come.
Sorry I posted this on Sunday as I do not like to post on Sunday (especially a rant) but this just bothered me too much.
Feed back wanted and I am grateful for it.
Thank you for your time I appreciate all of you
much love
Wendy "Sunshine" Harbaugh
I just don't feel like I am "Sunshine" today
Nickname I was given in high school becasue I brought a little ray of sunshine into all my friends lives and so they started calling me that. I feel like I brought a dark cloud today.
Don't let haters like that get you down! Especially those haters that post anonymously! Ugh! You were absolutely right to pursue publication of your beautiful patterns and I think having them published at Annies Attic will reach more crafters over the years than any tutorial on a blog. Also, any internet user knows to print out or download instructions lest they disappear unexpectedly. Your work is truly inspirational! .
ReplyDeleteHi Wendy
ReplyDeletebeing part of your blog and watching the things you make grow into beautiful pieces of art and craft, I get the feeling you are a warm and friendly person who loves sharing what you learn and make for your family and friends. Either for gain or pleasure that is for you to decide you owe no-one explanation, I for one bought your book and couldn't wait for it to arrive I will be buying another for a friend as a gift soon. As I said I feel warmth from your love of craft and icy cold from anonymous who probably hasn't got a clue how to love or make anything at all. love and hugs from Liverpool England June xx
How does that saying go .. you can please some of the people some of the time but not all of the people, all of the time? something like that?
ReplyDeleteYou are entitled to make a living. period.
Keep your chin up ..
Julie Andrea
I find your blog and work an inspiration. It has lead me to try new things, like Romanian Lace, that I would never have done. With all that you have given to me through your work here I am so delighted that you can make a living at it. You deserve to publish and be recognized for the good work you do. There are always ugly people making ugly comments but the good out weigh the bad by far.
ReplyDeletePS I bought the YoYo book and love it. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteBottom line,this is your blog, your space and you do not have to explain anything. Keep it all in perspective and remember how many more (lots!) of happy readers you have. Don't let the minority spoil it for you. It is just impossible to please everyone all of the time. Keep doing what you are doing.We (and there's lots ofus) enjoy and appreciate what you do.
ReplyDeleteYou wrote:
ReplyDelete"Ladies if you can feed your family and work from home and be a full time mom go to all the school events and take care of the kids when they are sick by all means give up a copyright or two or more"
And as a work from home Mum who does just that and is currently paying the mortgage while my DH is a student, I say thank you for being so eloquent and correct!
I thought that these things happen only in my country. Now I see that people are the same everywhere - grateful and ungrateful. Some come, cheer up, write a comment. Others are only interested in their own benefit and there is not thanks for the gift received. I have a similar problem. I try to share what I learned about bobbin lace. I give my patterns and tutorials completely for free and then I see that are sold elsewhere. I wanted to give up, but there is the second part of the decent people for whom I do like.
ReplyDeleteI think that what you are doing is great. Please, do not be disgusted! We need teachers, authors of book, enthusiasts like you, let everything beautiful in the world isn´t disappeared.
Please excuse my English.
I want to thank you all. I had a horrid day yesterday and this was a sort of thing that was the straw that broke the camels back. I really appreciate all of you and your continued support of me and my blog and for those that have bought books for some support to my family's needs. I am indebted and grateful
ReplyDeleteMuch love
Wendy
I'm a lurker... but I have to come out of the woodwork on this one.
ReplyDeleteYou have every right to be upset with someone coming in to your website and wagging their finger at you (and others).
It is a foolish and selfish person who doesn't think to take into consideration all the facts and attacks.
Long live Free Enterprise!
-Elsie
You are so lucky to have a publisher notice you and offer to pay you what you love to do so much that most of the time you do it for free. I am so happy that you have had that opportunity and I am going to go buy a copy of the book this weekend. Everyone who supports your work should write a thank-you note to Annie's Attic for providing a professionally done publication of one of our favorite projects.
ReplyDeleteOkay, I have you on my Google Reader feed and I usually just glance at your beautiful work, never really taking the time to read your blogs. I read this one. I love that you want to talk openly about this subject. As a crocheter myself, I know how long it takes to just make something off a pattern. My mind reels at the thought of creating a pattern, let alone a tutorial, from scratch.
ReplyDeleteI was originally drawn to your blog because of your yoyo tutorial. I loved that it was free. After reading this I want to buy the book. God bless Annie's Attic for bringing some well deserved income into your home. I'm seriously fired up about buying books before I browse for free patterns now. I think as a community, we should support our fellow crafters. Otherwise, you're right. The art will die.
Thank you!
Wendy...don't let people like that get you down. Anyone should realize that you deserve the blessing having your patterns in a book is...you deserve it!!!! I hope the rest of your week is awesome.
ReplyDeleteThanks again to those that have left comments several have made me cry in a good way I love you all and appreciate you much love wendy
ReplyDeletewell thank goodness you are feeling better about things, now get back to work and start thinking creatively we need you to inspite us!! love june xx
ReplyDeleteIt's been over a year since this was posted and I hope you've taken everyone's positive comments to heart and brushed off any further negative comments you've received!
ReplyDeleteYou are the giver! You are the creator! Remember that. Some people get mad because they don't know how to do think for themselves and have to rely on others to do the thinking for them. I am a very crafty person, but we all take inspiration from others. Thank you for yours!
ReplyDelete